How a Business Coach Can Help You Develop a Hiring Strategy That Builds the Team You Actually Want to Work With
- Ashley Boaz
- Sep 15
- 6 min read
Hiring isn’t just about filling positions—it’s about intentionally creating the kind of team you actually want to work with. Too many business owners rush the hiring process, only to end up with people who don’t align with their company’s culture, values, or long-term vision. The result? Frustration, wasted time, high turnover, and stalled growth.
This is where working with a business coach can completely transform the way you hire. A skilled coach won’t just help you define the roles you need; they’ll guide you through clarifying your vision, identifying your core values, and mapping out what your ideal team player actually looks like. With this clarity, you can create a hiring strategy that attracts the right candidates, repels the wrong ones, and builds a team you’re proud to lead.
In this article, we’ll explore how to design a hiring strategy with the help of a business coach, covering:
Why vision and values should come before job postings
How to map out your ideal team player
The must-haves for every new hire
The “absolutely not’s” that disqualify candidates
Steps to build a hiring process you can trust
How a business coach can hold you accountable and streamline the process
By the end, you’ll see that building your dream team is less about chance and more about strategy.
Why Vision and Core Values Must Guide Your Hiring Strategy
If you don’t know where your business is headed, it’s impossible to know who belongs on your team. Many entrepreneurs make the mistake of hiring for immediate needs—like “we need someone to answer phones” or “we need someone who can manage social media”—without considering whether that hire aligns with the company’s future direction.
A business coach will push you to step back and define your vision. Ask yourself:
What do I want my company to look like 5 years from now?
What kind of culture do I want my team to experience every day?
How do I want clients and customers to feel when they interact with my business?
From this vision, you can establish core values—the principles that guide every decision and interaction. Core values are more than nice words on a wall. They’re the foundation of your team dynamic. For example, your values might include:
Integrity: Doing the right thing even when no one is watching.
Growth mindset: Always looking for ways to improve.
Collaboration: Valuing teamwork over ego.
Accountability: Taking ownership of results.
When your hiring strategy is rooted in your vision and values, you stop hiring out of desperation and start building with intention. A business coach can help you articulate these values clearly, so you can filter every candidate through them.
Mapping Out Your Ideal Team Player
Once you’ve clarified your vision and values, it’s time to define what your ideal team player looks like. This isn’t just about skills or years of experience—it’s about behaviors, attitudes, and personality traits that align with your company.
Start by asking:
What characteristics do my best employees or team members already share?
What kind of personalities thrive in our work environment?
What skills or traits would make collaboration smoother?
For example, if you’re running a fast-paced startup, your ideal team player might be adaptable, proactive, and comfortable with change. If you’re running a client-focused service business, empathy, communication, and patience might top your list.
A business coach can help you create a detailed profile of your ideal candidate for each role, not just in terms of job description, but also in terms of cultural fit. This step saves you from making costly mistakes—like hiring someone technically skilled but toxic to your team dynamic.
Defining Your “Must-Haves”
Every role will have non-negotiable skills or traits. Your hiring strategy should make these clear upfront so you’re not wasting time with the wrong candidates.
Examples of “must-haves” might include:
Skill-based must-haves: Proficiency in specific software, certifications, or technical abilities.
Behavioral must-haves: Strong communication, adaptability, problem-solving, or teamwork.
Cultural must-haves: Alignment with your company values, willingness to learn, positive attitude.
For instance, if one of your core values is accountability, then every candidate must demonstrate responsibility for past work and results. A business coach can help you identify the true “must-haves” for your company and ensure they’re reflected in your job postings, interview questions, and evaluation criteria.
Defining Your “Absolutely Not’s”
Just as important as knowing what you want is knowing what you absolutely won’t tolerate. These are the dealbreakers that disqualify candidates—even if their resume is impressive.
Examples of “absolutely not’s” might include:
Lack of respect for deadlines or commitments
Poor communication or defensiveness when given feedback
Negative attitude or constant complaining
Lack of integrity or honesty
Disregard for teamwork or collaboration
Creating this list upfront helps you avoid the trap of “settling” for someone just because they seem competent on paper. A business coach can help you stay disciplined here, reminding you that one bad hire can disrupt your entire team.
Building a Hiring Process You Can Trust
Now that you’ve mapped out your vision, values, must-haves, and dealbreakers, it’s time to put a process in place. A strong hiring process doesn’t just happen—it’s designed.
Here are the steps a business coach might recommend:
1. Write Job Descriptions That Reflect Values, Not Just Tasks
Instead of listing duties, highlight the type of person who thrives in your company. Use language that speaks to culture as much as skill. For example:
“We’re looking for a proactive, adaptable team player who thrives in a fast-paced environment and shares our commitment to integrity and collaboration.”
2. Use Pre-Screening to Filter Early
Before interviews, include application questions or assessments that reveal alignment with your values. For example: “Describe a time you took ownership of a mistake and how you handled it.”
3. Conduct Behavioral Interviews
Don’t just ask about skills—ask about past behavior, since it’s the best predictor of future performance. Questions like:
“Tell me about a time you had to collaborate with a difficult teammate.”
“What’s a recent example of you going above and beyond for a customer or client?”
4. Include Team Involvement
Have key team members meet candidates to gauge chemistry and cultural fit. Often, existing employees can spot misalignment faster than leadership.
5. Trust Red Flags
If something feels off—even if the resume looks perfect—don’t ignore it. Your “absolutely not’s” exist for a reason.
By building a process that screens for values and behaviors as much as skills, you’ll reduce turnover, improve morale, and create a workplace you’re proud of.
How a Business Coach Elevates the Process
While you can do all of this on your own, a business coach accelerates the process and holds you accountable. Here’s how they help:
Clarity – They guide you in articulating your vision, values, and ideal candidate profiles.
Objectivity – They keep you from making emotional or rushed decisions during hiring.
Accountability – They ensure you stick to the hiring strategy instead of settling.
Efficiency – They help you design streamlined processes that save time.
Confidence – They give you the tools and frameworks to trust your decisions.
A business coach becomes a partner in building your dream team, ensuring you’re not just filling seats but intentionally crafting a culture and workforce aligned with your goals.
Final Thoughts: Building the Team You Want Starts With Strategy
Hiring is one of the most critical skills a business owner can develop. The right team can elevate your business, while the wrong hires can derail progress and drain resources. By working with a business coach, you gain the clarity, discipline, and strategy needed to build a team you actually want to work with.
Start by defining your vision and core values. Map out your ideal team player. Set clear must-haves and absolutely not’s. Then, design a hiring process that screens for these qualities consistently.
With the right strategy in place, hiring becomes less of a gamble and more of a powerful tool for growth. And the best part? You’ll create a team that inspires you, supports your mission, and makes running your business not just more successful—but more enjoyable.
Your next chapter of growth is waiting. The only question is—are you ready to go after it?Contact Mint Conceptions team of HR consultants, business coaches, and business consultants to help tailor solutions to fit your unique business needs.
Comments